When
a new Prime Minister or Chief Minister takes charge, their performance is
generally not reviewed within 6 months to one year. Ironically, in the
case of Narendra Modi, the review of his performance started even before he
assumed office. Modi’s poll campaign created high expectations among the people,
so much so that people expected India’s problems of 65 years, to be
solved within a day of his becoming Prime Minister. In the first week of
September 2014, Modi completed 100 days in office as the Prime Minister. Almost the entire media reviewed his 100 days’ performance.
On
behalf of your ezine PreSense, we conducted a quick online/offline survey to
assess how people perceived the ‘Modi Sarkar’ at the end of its 100
day rule. Nearly 70% of the respondents gave a rating of over 80% for his
vision, governance and communication. So it seems that Modi continues to enjoy
the confidence of the people.
Achievements
The
respondents were asked to indicate one single achievement of Modi’s governance
that they considered outstanding. What stood out were his foreign policy
initiatives, that is, the manner in which he got down quickly to build/rebuild
relationships with foreign countries. His vision for the nation and commitment
to goals, use of technology in governance, his direct communication
with the citizens through the social media, and his ‘Make in India’ campaign
were considered the great achievements of his first 100 days. Less government
and more governance was his motto during the elections and it has now been
amplified to effective governance.
When
we interacted offline with some various groups, including political adversaries
of Modi, they hailed his initiatives such as maintaining good relations with
foreign countries and marketing India. Many appreciated his focus
on increasing the contribution of the manufacturing sector to the GDP, to
improve it from 16% to 25%.
A
senior bureaucrat from Delhi told us on conditions of anonymity that he
could see a sea change in the discipline of bureaucrats and other staff
members. He said ministers and officials got the uncanny feeling that
they were being monitored by an ‘invisible eye’.
Another
bureaucrat told us in confidence that though Modi’s experiences were drawn from
a state administration, he understood the nuances of Central administration
well and adapted himself very quickly. He started clearing the stumbling
blocks to good governance. “We will be able to see the results of his
governance within two years”, he added.
The
leader of a political party admitted that Modi’s constant contact with the
youth through the social media was his ‘master stroke’ that would produce long
term gains. A ruling party leader admitted that Modi had a huge back
office of social media experts working on analysis of feedback received from
the public. Thanks to his communication style, Modi has become an icon among
the youth both in India and abroad. He seems to galvanise the positive
energies in people, including the youth, towards nation building activities.
Expectations Not Yet Fulfilled
In
our study, we also asked the people about their unfulfilled expectations from
Modi, and the issues that needed attention. Many of the respondents were of the
view that Modi needed to focus more on the internal issues, such as price rise,
power crisis and unemployment. Many of them felt that the
initiatives to curb corruption and repatriate black money from the Swiss banks
were not visible, as promised during the election campaign. (Incidentally, Modi
has set up a high-powered committee to devise ways and means to bring back
money, siphoned out of the country by politicians and industrialists. The
committee is to submit a report shortly to the government. Also, the Swiss
banks have agreed in principle to share information about the source from which
they receive funds).
One
of the professors of a reputed institute confided that Modi should control some
of his indiscreet party colleagues, spreading ‘hate messages’ while Modi
was emphasising ‘inclusive growth and development’.
One
of the main criticisms against Modi’s style of governance by his party members
was that in the process of improving governance, Modi had distanced
himself from the party leaders and cadre. Modi was known for his easy
accessibility to all when he was the Chief Minister of Gujarat. In
the name of ‘minimum government and maximum governance’, he centralised the
authoritative powers at the Prime Minister’s Office. Quoting the recent
setback because of the party’s poor performance in the bye-elections, party men
feared that continued disconnect with the party cadre could adversely affect
their political performance in the long run.
Modi and the Media
During
the past ten years, Modi had faced a hostile media. After assuming office
as Prime Minister, Modi kept the mainline media away from his tours. He
advised his ministers and Members of Parliament to refrain from speaking to the
media unnecessarily. The way things look now, Modi intends to focus more on
performance than promises. Unlike his predecessors, Modi does not have a high
profile media advisor but carried over his PA from Gujarat who doubles up as
his media advisor.
He
reportedly told leading editors in Delhi that he would directly get in touch
with them if there was a major newsbreak. Modi’s main mode of public
communication is the social media. This style has evoked mixed reactions from
the journalists.
No
doubt, 100 days is too short a period for a fair evaluation of Modi’s
governance. Cutting across party lines and age, the survey indicated that
Modi has emerged as a ‘strong and dependable leader’ of India, the only one
after Indira Gandhi. He has inspired and ignited hope in the hearts of
the Indian youth in India and abroad. A senior journalist said that Modi is
among those rare leaders in the recent past who inspire confidence in the
people.
Sum up
In
spite of initial hiccups, Modi has already emerged as a leader of international
stature, judging by his address at the 69th session of the UN General Assembly
in New York recently. He focused on issues of global importance such as water,
sanitation, cleanliness and of course eradication of poverty and the united
fight against terrorism caused by fissiparous elements regrouping themselves
across the world. Modi told the world from the august podium of the UNGA that
he was a leader to watch for, and diplomats have already started comparing him
to international leaders like Kennedy and Thatcher, in the manner in which
he looks at global issues and addresses them. Modi’s message against groupings,
‘G-8 or G-20 should actually give way to G-all’ emphasised that all nations
should come together for a common goal of development instead of a group of
rich nations determining the destiny of all. Diplomats have hailed this
approach.
The
industry back home and others in the politico socio cultural milieu claim he is
the best bet for India and would lead the nation to greater heights and
prosperity. For this, he needs to be given more time and space and a free
hand, sans impatient cynicism. Give him the allowance of a couple of years to
effect the positive changes he wants to bring to the nation. The process of
unwinding from a system of 65 years of bureaucratic cocoon takes time.
By K. Srinivasan, Editor in Chief, PreSense